Mathieu received a rating of 95 after being named All-Pro first team for the second year in consecutive years. In 2020, he had six interceptions and one recovery of a fumble, returning one of his picks for an interception.
The Chiefs managed to finish in the top 10 for scoring defense during their second consecutive year thanks to the 29-year old.
He's also just a few points in front of Arizona Cardinals star Budda Baker (93 rating) and was named All-Pro on the first team after scoring 118 tackles in 2020.
Devin McCourty, a veteran of the New England Patriots, was also well-respected with a an overall 93, but not getting much recognition elsewhere. In the 10 years of service, McCourty is 33 years old and has only had one appearance in the Pro Bowl.